Search:

It's Not the Time

Moving onto European Standard Time will not plunge Scotland in to a nuclear winter. It also won't do much else.

by Ross Jones-morris, 11th February 2012

"It is no secret that Tories in the south want to leave Scotland in darkness, but fixing the clocks to British summertime would mean that dawn wouldn't break until nearly 9am."

With all of the sardonic candour that only an opposition politician could muster, SNP MP Angus MacNeil public denounces David Cameron's support for moving the clocks forward by an hour in order to align with Central European Time. And many, many people agree with him.

articleimages/Motorwayatnightbydarkskyz.jpg

The threat of dark mornings for commuters is one of the main reasons for Scotland's doubts

The announcement that the government has backed a bid for the UK to move its clocks forward for a three year trial period has been met with dissenting voices, especially from the devolved powers. With these doubts ringing in Parliament's ears, Cameron has backed the plan with Business Secretary Edward Davey stating that, "as the prime minister has made clear, we would need consensus from the devolved administrations if any change were to take place".

So what's all the fuss about? The pro-time change lobby tell of the practical benefits that such a change will bring. Lower road deaths and reduced carbon dioxide emissions in the lighter evenings (although nothing said of the darker mornings). And of course the catch all of 'improved health'. It will also reasonably allow for more time when many of us are in bed to be spent in extra daylight in the evenings being just generally more active (I am also aware that I write this as cowering from the glaring sunshine shining into my dimly lit office).

It seems politically unfeasible to go ahead with the proposed changes without unanimous enforcement

The main opposition can be found in the form of the Scottish Parliament with the SNP denouncing the changes as dangerous and sometimes (as Angus MacNeil oh-so-subtly insinuated) anti-Scottish.

This may just seem like they are jumping on a nationalist bandwagon. But there is some evidence to back up their claims. When a similar trial was carried out from 1968 to 1971, Northern Scotland saw a net increase in the number of people seriously killed or injured on their roads. Though this may be quite a small and relatively sparsely populated part of the United Kingdom, it should not be ignored. And the majority of the UK it seems would hardly notice the change. All us southerners would really be faced with is the novel prospect of watching Newsnight in daylight and eating breakfasts in the dark. This may be odd but it won't threaten our health.

Scotland isn't some sort of arctic leper colony, at the whim of a tyrannical English parliament

The response of many has been, so what? It's not like Scotland is going to be plunged (a somewhat ominous word used all too often in the coverage of this story) into some sort of nuclear winter, foraging around for fried mars bars and haggis amongst the panic induced glassings that would surely claim all but the most savage. Scotland isn't some sort of arctic leper colony, at the whim of a tyrannical English parliament intent on their unpleasant and sunlight deficient demise. Let's remember that (as the government has said) Scotland will get it's say and that those Scots are not too different from the English. Why can't we all just get along?

Anyway, let's just hope that they say no because firstly I am currently grievously underwhelmed by the proposed changes, but most importantly I do like a nice dark evening sitting in front of the TV ignoring the overblown party politics of the SNP.

Comments

There are no comments yet

To comment, please sign in or register.

The Alligator Superblog: latest posts

Jane Eyre at the Rosemary Branch

| Fri 3 May 2013

Why bother? Why would you even try to adapt Jane Eyre into a dramatic production? The novel is an almost perfect period piece preserving the archit ...

It's a Bloody Drum

| Tue 16 Apr 2013

The hang is not a drum. It is a hang. Do not call it a drum. This misnomer creates "a ripple effect of misinformation that leads to damaged inst ...

The DRC Elections: Raising more questions than answers?

| Sat 11 Feb 2012

The DRC made the headlines at the end of last year for electoral malpractice and violence and was treated with weary cynicism by the majority of news ...

Student Signals

| Sat 11 Feb 2012

Politics has often obscured economics in the raucous debate on tuition fees, perhaps rightly so given the plausible case that to model education as a ...

The War on Terror is far from won

| Sat 11 Feb 2012

In the past week the headlines have looked like the stuff of fairy tales: Cinderella has got her Prince, and the bad guy is dead. Am I the only one ...

Moldova’s 2011 Local Elections will confirm its European Orientation

| Sat 11 Feb 2012

Moldova remains stuck in a state of political upheaval initiated by the inability of the Communists to win the constitutionally required 61 seats to ...